Why 'free' tax filing ends up costing money
Last checked Nov 18, 2026 · How we check
Most free editions cover only a simple Form 1040. Itemizing, self-employment, rental income or a home sale usually pushes you into a paid tier. IRS Free File providers can also charge for state returns or if you miss their own limits.
The facts, with sources
| Item | What we found | Source |
|---|---|---|
| When Free File can still cost money | State returns, failing the provider's own rules, or AGI over the limitWhat the source saysAn IRS Free File Guided Tax provider may charge a fee for (1) state tax return preparation and filing, (2) when the filer does not qualify for a free federal tax return based on the provider’s eligibility criteria, (3) when the filer’s adjusted gross income (AGI) exceeds the Guided Tax program’s AGI threshold for eligibility. | irs.gov, checked Nov 18, 2026 |
| Doesn't qualify | Itemized deductions on Schedule A, such as charitable gifts, medical costs, mortgage interest, state and local taxesWhat the source saysItemized deductions claimed on Schedule A, like charitable contributions, medical expenses, mortgage interest and state and local tax deductions | turbotax.intuit.com, checked Nov 18, 2026 |
| Doesn't qualify | Home sale, mortgage interest, rental income; freelance or self-employed incomeWhat the source saysSale of home, real estate taxes, mortgage interest, or rental property income/losses Freelance, contractor, side hustle, or self-employed income and expenses | taxact.com, checked Nov 18, 2026 |
| Who qualifies | About 52% of filers; Form 1040 with no schedules except EITC, Child Tax Credit, student loan interest and retirement distributionsWhat the source saysApproximately 52% of filers qualify for H&R Block Online Free Edition. Simple tax situations only (Form 1040 and no schedules except Earned Income Tax Credit, Child Tax Credit, Student Loan Interest, and Retirement Plan Distributions). | hrblock.com, checked Nov 18, 2026 |
Why people get caught out
"Free" versions have income, age and form limits, and the state return often costs extra. One example is a Reddit thread comparing what TaxAct and FreeTaxUSA charged one filer. Check the limits below before you start, not at checkout.
Which tax year this is
These are the terms posted on Nov 18, 2026, which mostly describe the 2025 tax year (returns filed in 2026). Companies post new terms for 2026 returns when filing season opens. The IRS says Free File reopens in January 2027. We'll re-check then, and the dates beside each fact show when we last read it.